Innovation in College Media

a group discussion about the future of student media
  • Home
  • About the CICM
    • Podcasts
  • CICM Story Project – Louisville
  • Consulting
  • Resources
    • College New Media Map
    • Free online tools
    • Important College Press Cases
    • Social Media Guidelines
  • What people say

Blog

Search Results

← Previous Entries
Next Entries →

On comments

6:50 pm in industry news

Image representing New York Times as depicted ...

Image via CrunchBase

The news industry has entered another round of comment concerns. The New York Times just implemented a new “Trusted Commenter” system that requires a connection to your Facebook account. Gannett announced last month that they’re switching their comments system to one that uses Facebook Connect.

And the college media listserv had a recent round of e-mails about the advantages of using Facebook log-ins for comments.

There are obvious arguments for going with the FB log-in. People are less likely to be nasty, brutish or mean when their “real” names are associated with what they say in a comment section. Facebook log-ins are an easy turn-key method of authenticating user names. And the FB log-in is becoming ubiquitous. Randy Lovely, senior vice president of news & audience development, doesn’t mention Gannett’s company-wide shift in an online chat about the new system, but admits that 81 percent of adults in their area have Facebook accounts.

I certainly understand the desire to have a community of commenters who are civil and reasonable in their comments about contentious issues of the day. And I can’t imagine the amount of time it takes a site like the New York Times to wade through comments every day.

But, as I’ve written before, I really don’t agree with the push to associate “authentic” real-world identities with comments on a web site.

First, these papers are outsourcing the “quality” of their site’s community to a third-party. And there are people who have legitimate issues with the entire Facebook platform, who don’t have accounts with FB and don’t want them. My parents, for instance, don’t have Facebook accounts. Should they be required to create such accounts to comment on a news site?

The second concern is a legitimate concern some people have about connecting their IRL (In Real Life) identity with comments they make online. I don’t have to go through all the hypothetical examples that have been hashed and rehashed in this arena, but suffice to say that there can be real implications for people if they say something negative about a controversial topic. So their voices will be effectively muzzled by “authenticity.”

You may think that’s a small price to pay for ridding comments sections of obvious trolls and boors who don’t know how to be polite. I’m not so sure. And I’m not so sure I’d be comfortable risking someone’s job because of something they said in a comment section.

There is a long history of pseudonymous commentary in American life. Some of it good, some of it bad. But I always thought the point was that we suffered the bad because the same rules protected the good.

In many ways, I keep coming back to what long-time blogger Anil Dash wrote earlier this year when this topic got hot again. Cultivating an online community of commenters is work, sometimes hard work. And Facebook Connect is a cop-out. And adopting the “authentic identity” paradigm just means the trolls have won.

Related articles
  • Poynter: NY Times introduces unmoderated comments for ‘trusted commenters’ (blogs.journalism.co.uk)
  • The Des Moines Register switch to Facebook-driven commenting system, a traffic killer? (nextlevelofnews.com)
Enhanced by Zemanta
PrintPrint Friendly

Comments Off

Six years and counting

8:00 am in CICM shop talk

Photo by Flickr user Ryskiphoto, used by permission under Creative Commons license.

Saturday marked the 6th blogiversary of this here effort. Since nobody reads blogs on Saturdays, I’m marking the occasion today. According to the most official source known to humankind, the anniversary is usually celebrated by gifts of iron, sugar, or wood objects.

About 130 posts over the last year (of 1,930 since the beginning), all but a handful by yours truly.

As I wrote last year,

On a personal note, there have been numerous people I could and should thank for the assistance and support over the past five years. Foremost among them are Chris Carroll and Ralph Braseth, who set this blog in motion in late 2005 with an e-mail asking me to set up a web site for them. “I’ll set up the site, but you have to provide the content.” You can see how well that worked.

I should also thank the many advisers who read and contribute in even small ways to make this blog what it is, and to College Media Association, Inc., for keeping this thing alive.

I’d also thank the many industry experts, young journalists and wizened professionals whom I’ve bugged over the years for interviews or assistance.

And, as always, my colleagues in the Journalism Department at Eastern Illinois University for their continued support of a non-traditional publishing format.

Hard to believe that when we began, YouTube was just taking off, Facebook was still limited to colleges and high schools, and nobody had even heard of Twitter or the iPhone or iPad.

Maybe it’s vain to mark anniversaries like this, but blog years are like dog years – longer than human years. I’ve watched many start up, burn bright and then flame out over the years. So it’s worth remembering every once in a while – even if I have to do it myself.

I’ve got some new ideas for the new year, and the new template is part of that. Keep reading, and contributing, so we can keep pushing college media forward.

Enhanced by Zemanta
PrintPrint Friendly

41881 Comment »http%3A%2F%2Fwww.collegemediainnovation.org%2Fblog%2F2011%2F11%2Fsix-years-and-counting%2FSix+years+and+counting2011-11-14+14%3A00%3A28Bryan+Murleyhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.collegemediainnovation.org%2Fblog%2F%3Fp%3D4188

Curated links for Friday, Nov. 11, 2011

9:00 am in Links

Friday linkage, some fun and some deep, and lots to think about. Happy Veteran’s Day, and it’s also 11/11/11, which means something – I’m not sure.

First, this was the tempest in a teapot this week from Poynter: Romenesko resigns after 12 years at Poynter. Poynter has been hammered in the comments. I’ll leave it to you to decide the merits of whatever it was that caused his abrupt departure. But someone on Twitter had the audacity to call him journalism’s Joe Paterno. Someone needs to get a grip, a clue and some perspective.

Mixel for iPad: A social art collage app. Free, and one of the authors is Koi Vihn, whose design ideas I’ve appreciated.

Smart is the new sexy (NAA): This is an ad campaign by the Newspaper Association of America. I suppose it’s trying to make newspapers “hip” or something through the use of pastels and sans serif fonts. Maybe I’m just too old to see the effectiveness.

What is Photojournalism (Ed Kashi): “Ed was asked recently by Whitney Johnson at the New Yorker magazine how he defined photojournalism today. Below is his response, illustrated with examples that highlight the 3 distinct parts of Ed’s definition.”

Ten technical Twitter tips for journalists (journalism.co.uk): For those new to the platform, or some tips for the longtime user.

We Are Journalists (tumblr): “We are journalists. We are proud of what we do. We are tired of bad press about the press. We are trying to be “team players.” We are terrified of more layoffs and paycuts. We would like to produce quality work without ‘obamasux99’ posting some non-sequitur rant at the end of it. We complain because we want things to be better. We would like some respect, plz. We are journalists.”

Cameras Everywhere: The Promise and Peril for Human Rights (MediaShift): It’s all fun and games until someone gets hurt.

The Social Graph is neither (Pinboard blog): “Social networks exist to sell you crap. The icky feeling you get when your friend starts to talk to you about Amway, or when you spot someone passing out business cards at a birthday party, is the entire driving force behind a site like Facebook.”

A Brief Rant On The Future of Interaction Design (Bret Victor): This is worth reading for its contrarian take on the future of interface design, and this paragraph: “Pictures Under Glass is an interaction paradigm of permanent numbness. It’s a Novocaine drip to the wrist. It denies our hands what they do best. And yet, it’s the star player in every Vision Of The Future.” is pure gold.

PrintPrint Friendly

Tags: Links
Comments Off

Currated links for Friday, Nov. 4, 2011

6:18 am in Links

YouTube has really been pushing socially interactive storytelling lately. The image above is from (obviously) Project Imagination. Check out the submitted photographs.

It’s Friday, time for some more light reading for your weekend. Since this is the weekend Daylight Savings Time begins for most of the U.S., don’t forget to set your clocks back an hour.

New AP guidelines endorse misuse of Twitter (Daily Dot): The AP proves the adage that companies don’t understand social media – again.

ESPN’s new social media strategy prohibits talent and reporters from breaking news on Twitter (Interchange Project): See above.

Is Google helping journalists, or co-opting them? (GigaOm): Google seems intent on messing up its core product, which is search. Mathew Ingram explores some of the pitfalls of the company’s new integration of Google+ profiles with news search results.

Yahoo! Debuts a More Personal Web With Its Fall Collection of Mobile and Social Products (Yahoo!): I have enough “personal news” apps on my devices, but Yahoo! jumps on the bandwagon with another one.

32 Ways Of Looking At Unemployment, In One Chart (NPR Planet Money): Nifty chart from Jacob Goldstein, Alyson Hurt and Jess Jiang that lets you compare U.S. unemployment rates across the demographic spectrum.

Less Is More: Using Social Media to Inspire Concise Writing (NYT): “How can online media like Twitter posts, Facebook status updates and text messages be harnessed to inspire and guide concise writing? In this lesson, students read, respond to and write brief fiction and nonfiction stories, and reflect on the benefits and drawbacks of “writing short.””

Enhanced by Zemanta
PrintPrint Friendly

Tags: Links
Comments Off

October Carnival of Journalism: Exploring new tools

9:05 am in Carnival of Journalism

Crossposted from my personal website – Bryan

photo by Flickr user Zoriah. Use permitted under Creative Commons license. Click to see more images from this photographer.

This month’s Carnival of Journalism takes us on a tour of a truly frightful house of promise and peril: the world of new gadgets and software tools.

To refresh your memory, the prompt for this month was:

How do you decide to dedicate time to a new tool/platform/gadget? What is the process you go through mentally? And then later – how do you convince others to go through that process? And, last: How do you ensure that the tools you do adopt are used once the “newness” factor fades?

Without further delay, here are some of the responses (links open in new tabs):

Alfred Hermida writes, “The starting point for this discussion is the public, not the tools. Talking about tools is the last thing we should be doing.”

Joe Gullo looks for “the community factor” for new software tools, but says the results are often lackluster: “The hardest part is sticking with the product. It could be the most amazing service or product, but something has to keep me going back and using it.”

Dave Cohn makes an important distinction when evaluating any new tool: “Most platforms/tools/gadgets are tactical – not strategic. You should always keep your strategy in mind so that you can evaluate a tool about whether or not it’s helping to achieve that final goal.”

Carrie Brown focuses on the “evangelism” part of the question, and gives a list of ways to help others see the advantages of new things. This is important for college j-students, especially. “Contrary to popular belief, many of these so-called “digital natives” are often neither savvy about new tech nor exceptionally eager to go beyond their Facebook and Internet Explorer (?!) comfort zones.”

Lauren Rabaino walks through the process and provides examples of the best tools: “The best tools are the ones that solve a coverage problem or put a significant twist on already-existing storytelling tools. Sometimes — and these are my favorite kind of tools — you stumble upon one that fills a huge need that you didn’t even realize you had.”

Jonathan Groves explains how he decides what products to stick with, providing examples along the way. As for convincing others? His approach is slightly different. Click the link to read it. “What’s important is that we choose what best fits us, not everyone else.”

Stijn Debrouwere makes his first appearance in the carnival this month (welcome!). In his post, he posits some fountational reasons why journalists don’t adopt new tools: “our industry is slowly amassing an unsettling amount of cargo cult behaviors: we’re imitating a 20th-century writing style and ethical code without the first idea about how these contribute to journalism that is informative, engaging and fair.”

Jack Lail reiterates that, although it’s painful, “… experiment you must, lest you end up still using a 14,400 baud model and Windows 98 for the rest of your, indeed, wretched life.”

Andrew Zaleski, another new carnivore, explains “Ultimately, I stick to one governing principle when it comes to social media: how will the respective tool improve (and make easier) my work as digital media editor for Urbanite magazine?”

 

Enhanced by Zemanta
PrintPrint Friendly

Tags: Carnival of Journalism
Comments Off

Curated links for Wednesday, Oct. 19, 2011

4:44 am in Links

Students Beware, Facebook Changes and Privacy: Karl Hughes digs into some of the changes to the new Facebook interface. I’m curious if students will really notice how much of their privacy is being given away by the new features, or if they’ll care?

The Ultimate WordPress Cheat Sheet: This is for the guts of WordPress programming, not CSS or HTML.

Digital Dualism versus Augmented Reality: “I fundamentally think this digital dualism is a fallacy. Instead, I want to argue that the digital and physical are increasingly meshed, and want to call this opposite perspective that implodes atoms and bits rather than holding them conceptually separate augmented reality.”

Figment (Found via someone on Twitter): “Figment is a community where you can share your writing, connect with other readers, and discover new stories and authors. Whatever you’re into, from sonnets to mysteries, from sci-fi stories to cell phone novels, you can find it all here.”

Google introduces “Infinite Digital Bootcase,” acts as virtual librarian: “Google introduced the newest form of bookcase to your browsers today — what it calls an “Infinite Digital Bookcase,” and damn does it look cool.” Certainly an interesting move as more publishers move into the tablet market. More info on the official Google blog.

Hollywood unions, networks and studios mount anti-piracy offensive: “A broad coalition of film studios, TV networks and entertainment industry labor groups has launched an education campaign to teach the public about the evils of piracy and prod their employees and union members to support an anti-piracy bill in Washington.

“Through internal videos, newsletters, emails and booths set up in company commissaries , media giants such as NBCUniversal, CBS, Viacom, Sony Pictures and Warner Bros. are encouraging their employees to join a newly formed group called Creative America, a grass-roots organization launched this summer to muster support in the creative community for tougher anti-piracy legislation.”

I wish people would stop using the word “grass-roots” to describe industry-backed efforts to influence policy. Also, the PROTECT IP Act will have some impact on students if its passed, so might be something to write about.

Internet links not libel, top court rules (CBC): Via @Hermida on Twitter, what should be obvious is recognized by the Canadian Supreme Court.

PrintPrint Friendly

Tags: Links
Comments Off

ICM Interview: Brad Arendt on mobile app development promise and pitfalls

2:10 pm in industry news

Editor’s note: Brad Arendt, director of student media at Boise State, is a contributor to the blog and a colleague of long standing. This is structured as an interview because Brad wants to offer a service to other members of the college media community. The interview audio is below, and a transcript below the fold.

Boise State Student Media launched version 2.0 of their mobile app Bronco Mobile (iTunes link)  this August. Student Media Director Brad Arendt shared some of the experience of building a college media mobile app from the ground up, and what he hopes to give back to the community, in this interview. The audio is about 30 minutes long. A transcript is below the fold.

If, after reading or listening, you’re interested in more details of Arendt’s future efforts, contact Brad at barendt@boisestate.edu. He will also be at the Fall National College Media Convention in Orlando Oct. 28-30 and will be available to answer questions there.

Click on the mp3 player below to listen. If you’re on an iDevice and it doesn’t work, click this link to listen to the mp3.

Read the rest of this entry →

PrintPrint Friendly

Comments Off

Curated Links for Wednesday, Oct. 5, 2011

3:52 pm in Links

Since Adele has cancelled part of her North American tour, another selection from NPR’s Tiny Desk Concert series. Just because.

SkillShare: This is probably a site that’s been around for a while, but a good source of both free and paid opportunities to learn new skill sets.

Creating a web literate planet (summary): Along the same lines, Mark Surman explains some of the efforts he’s helping to lead with Mozilla to train people to better use and make web-based tools. Lots of information.

Newsrooms Beta: Now Open to Everyone: Digg has just opened the doors of their new Newsrooms features to the world. I’m not a big Digg user, but I’m sure some of you will be interested in this development.

We’re hiring: Code in the public interest, make your mother proud: The Chicago Tribune is looking for people who can wrangle code.

Can a tweet be defamatory: Bob Tarantino takes up a topic which I suspect will be popping up quite a bit over the next few years, and one we discussed recently with Frank LoMonte of the SPLC.

Five steps to better TV stories: Take what you can from this to make better web video stories, as well.

How Technology Made Occupy Wall Street Both Irrelevant and Ubiquitous: I don’t think “irrelevant” is the word I’d use, but Mims’ thesis is provocative, and worth a look. I suspect there will be a lot of similar “What It All Means” articles about the recent Occupy protests happening in the U.S. I’d venture that about 1 in 10 will be right.

5 Things Blogging Taught Me About Tweeting: This is helpful if you’ve ever been a blogger. But the tips are also helpful for anyone who wants to start or better understand Twitter. via @buffer on Twitter.

The Facebook Follow: Facebook wants to follow you everywhere around the Internet.

Tool of the Day: Animoto Animoto has been around a while. It’s a service that automatically generates a video out of photos and music that you upload to the service. It’s free to try out, but if you want more features, you’ll need to upgrade to a pro account, or – if you’re an educator – register for the educational license, which will give you and your students some of the features of the pro account.

PrintPrint Friendly

Tags: Links
Comments Off

Occupy Wall Street coverage in the student media

11:47 am in College Media

UPDATE: A sympathetic protest has sprung up called OccupyColleges. Here is their Facebook page.

The past several weeks, protesters have occupied Zuccotti Park near Wall Street in New York City. There have been scuffles with police, and arrests on the Brooklyn Bridge. The protests have taken the name OccupyWallStreet.

Many of the protesters appear to be young people, college students or recent graduates, who are upset about the state of the economy and their job prospects.

Which makes this a story for college media. I’m starting to keep a log of some of the coverage of the protests, which appear to be spreading to other cities.


  • The Rutgers Daily Targum has a story and photos about RU students who attended the protests (screenshot above).
  • Salisbury University’s The Flyer has a story about the protests: The “99%” Occupy Wall Street.
  • The independent The Justice student newspaper at Brandeis has this story: Alum arrested during Wall Street protests.

If your student outlet has covered this protest movement, e-mail me a link to scmurley -at- gmail.com or send it via Twitter to @cicm.

PrintPrint Friendly

Comments Off

Curated links for Monday, Oct. 3, 2011

3:46 pm in Links


NPR’s Tiny Desk Concert series, on YouTube. Just because.

Here are a few articles worth reading that I’ve found in my wanderings across the Internet over the past few days.

Hyperlocal Publishers Form a Trade Union: Some big names in hyperlocal journalism are behind this effort, which is a sensible networking alternative for small online publishers. Look forward to how it develops.

Like them or not, the latest changes to Facebook offer big ideas for news orgs: Some lessons that might be applicable from Facebook’s recent changes, by Gina Chen at Nieman Journalism Lab. Prepare to have your biases tweaked.

Rawporter: A mobile app that supposedly connects media outlets with citizens who have breaking news footage. Launching soon. This is an explanatory video.

Rusbridger: Twitter is no substitute for professional reporting: I love the first comment: “It’s true, Twitter is not like reporting. Also, spoons are not like lampposts.” Yep.

Judith Miller: ‘Just what kind of journalism is Poynter promoting?’: Based on a Poynter online course about “Covering Islam in America,” Miller, now a FOX News personality, goes on a jihad.

WSJ.com begins tracking personal user information without consent: “The Wall Street Journal has revised the privacy policy for WSJ.com to permit the site to connect a user’s Web browsing data with personally identifiable information without consent. Previously, the policy stated that it would ask for users’ permission before doing so.” I am beginning to think it might be time for America to have a serious discussion about online privacy. If we could stop being distracted by shiny objects.

How News Organizations Can Cut Down On The Email Overload: Can’t we all use some help in this department?

Making it Work With a Small Staff + Other ONA notes: Sean Blanda shares some notes and observations from a nuts and bolts panel discussion at the Online News Association Conference. Includes a video of the entire talk.

Teaching in the Quickly Changing Digital Age: An SND Takeaway: Aaron Manful pulled together the handout here with lots of information for people who want to get up to speed based on a session we did at the Society of News Design conference in St. Louis.

A network infrastructure for journalists online: Paul Bradshaw explains why journalists need to understand RSS readers, social networks, and social bookmarking to navigate the new online news world. Detailed information worth your while.

Is Branded Journalism Still Journalism?: They’ve been trying to rename it for years, but it’s public relations and marketing. I don’t have a problem with journalists who go into this field, either.

Your idea sucks, now go do it anyway: Some inspiration from Jason Cohen, a start-up guy.

Twitter ban’s constitutionality debated at UNC football panel: Interesting discussion for First Amendment Day about athletics, Twitter, and free speech rights.

PrintPrint Friendly

Comments Off

← Previous Entries
Next Entries →

Subscribe for e-mail blog posts

Enter your Email


Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

Subscribe to the ICM Digital Sherpa e-mail

Sign up for a weekly curated newsletter

On Twitter

Categories

Archives

College Media

  • @Omar Sofradzija
  • David Simpson
  • Kenna Griffin

Industry

  • News by Design

Organizations

  • AEJMC
  • Associated Collegiate Press
  • CNBAM
  • College Broadcasters
  • College Media Advisers
  • JACC
  • JEA Digital Media
  • Poynter Institute
  • Society for Collegiate Journalists
  • Society for Professional Journalists
  • Student Press Law Center
  • UPIU

Others

  • 10,000 Words
  • Adam Westbrook
  • Alfred Hermida
  • Andrew Cline
  • Andy Bechtel
  • Andy Dickinson
  • Chris Anderson
  • College Media Matters
  • Daniel Bachhuber
  • Doug Fisher
  • Future Journalism Project
  • Howard Owens
  • Jack Lail
  • John Robinson
  • Mark Hamilton
  • Mark Potts
  • Mindy McAdams
  • Paul Conley
  • Public Journalism Network
  • Ryan Sholin
  • Serena Carpenter
  • Steve Yelvington
  • Student Activism
  • Will Sullivan

z-Fallow

  • Danny Sanchez
  • Lucas Grindley
  • Meranda Watling
  • News Videographer

View My Stats



Innovation in College Media is proudly powered by WordPress and BuddyPress. Just another WordPress Theme developed by Themekraft.