You are browsing the archive for Advising.

Finding themselves

July 1, 2007 in Advising, career talk

There’s an early episode of “The Cosby Show” where Cliff’s daughter brings a new boyfriend home. He says that once he finishes high school, he wants to take a year to find himself. And Cliff responds, “In a year, you should be able to find yourself … and three or four other people.”

In the past several years, I’ve noticed an increasing number of talented students and recent grads who don’t seem all that interested in entering – or remaining in – the journalism world. They choose to take 6 months or a year to “find themselves.” That sounds noble but it often ends up where they “find themselves” living back with their parents, paying off credit card bills they ran up in college and working at Starbucks. But … they don’t seem all that upset that they’ve left the newspaper world so soon.

Sure, there are also those driven student journalists who can spot opportunity and take advantage of it. But the balance seems to have shifted some. Even while they’re still in college, I find it harder to sell students on the idea of college media being an investment for them. For one, leisure time is something fewer students seem willing to sacrifice. Maybe that mind-set is carrying over into their first jobs.

So I’m wondering if we as advisers aren’t doing a good job of “selling” this as a career, or if more students are simply seeing something out there they don’t like.

And I’m also wondering if I sound like someone’s cranky grandpa who starts every sentence with, “In my day …”

UPDATE: Be sure to read John Robinson’s take on this topic: Finding yourselves in journalism – ed.

ONA contest deadline: one category for students

June 15, 2007 in Academics, Advising, Multimedia views

Melissa Worden points out the deadline for the 2007 Online News Association awards: June 30, 2007. Here are complete details.

There’s one category that should interest college media types:

 Student journalism: This category honors excellence in digital journalism by a student or team reporting on a single story or issue. The work must have appeared originally in a student- or school-based Web site and have been created by full-time student(s) (at the time of publication). Unpublished entries do not qualify.

Cost of entry is $50-$100, depending on how many visitors your site gets each month. I’d love to see a college media outlet win this award, as opposed to the class-produced projects that usually crop up in this type of contest. Nothing against those folks, but producing multimedia on deadline for a student-directed publication is vastly different from coming up with one whiz-bang project with the help of professors during an entire semester.

Brave new world

June 7, 2007 in Advising

I’ve spent the past two days at the Rockford (Ill.) Register Star, specifically to soak up the culture change of a newsroom that has committed to putting all breaking news online first. What I soaked up was a completely new world.

For a few years as an adviser, I would spend a couple of weeks every summer in that newsroom, either as a reporter or a copy editor. My bosses at NIU were smart enough to see the value in this and allow me a couple of weeks away when the students weren’t around. It’s been several years now since I’ve done this – completely my fault and far too long, I quickly realized.

The newsroom looks the same and many of the same faces are there, but everything has changed.

One reporter and one copy editor start at 6 a.m., writing and filing short stories for the Web. These range from briefs, like a quick weather forecast and overnight police and fire reports, to full-blown scoops. This morning, for example, an acquaintance in Hong Kong e-mailed one of the editors an AP photo of a Rockford-area woman who was a contestant on Bob Barker’s final “The Price Is Right” show, taped yesterday. Before 7 a.m., the reporter, Sadie Gurman, had localized the AP story about Barker and it was online. By 8, she had spoken by cell phone to the local winner, still in Los Angeles, and had filed another update. Turns out that the woman was the show’s big winner, snagging two cars, a cruise and other stuff.

Online readers knew all of this a full 24 hours earlier than they would have just a couple years ago, when editors would have simply prepared the story for the next day’s paper and then sat on it, praying that competing TV and radio stations didn’t find out about it. The story would have made it onto the Web site, but only after the print edition hit the streets.  

No longer. “News Now” stories are posted online every few minutes and show up as a scrolling list at the top of the homepage, each with a time stamp. Where once the paper updated its site three or four times on a good day, today 40, 50, 60 daily updates are commonplace. The record stands at 71, I’m told.

Sure, there’s risk that electronic competitors will see these stories, pursue them and air them before the next day’s paper comes out. Too bad. The term I heard often was “repurpose,” as in repurposing the day’s online content for the next day’s newspaper. Not the other way around.

Project stories and non-breaking news often still get published simultaneously in print and online (after being promoted online). Sometimes longer versions of the online updates appear in print the next day. But everything is carefully integrated. User traffic to the day’s online updates stories helps determine story placement in both media.

Reporters have at their disposal several “mojo” – short for mobile journalist – backpacks. Each is stocked with a laptop computer equipped with a cellular phone card; a point-and-shoot digital camera that also can shoot digital; a digital audio recorder and a detachable microphone. Photographers are being trained to shoot and edit video; I spent a large chunk of this morning watching photographer/videographer Alan Leon edit a piece about a man with brain cancer.

It’s one thing to know and understand that these kinds of changes are occurring in journalism. It’s quite another to spend time in a newsroom where it’s happening. Compare it to the difference between studying a foreign language and spending time in the country where it’s spoken.

I can’t emphasize enough how important it is for advisers to regularly spend a day or two in an online-oriented newsroom. I once did this yearly exercise simply to keep my skills sharp. By the end of the two weeks I’d feel pretty confident that my reporting and editing skills weren’t wasting away. After the past two days, I realize I now have to do it or risk falling hopelessly behind the relevancy curve.

I plan to visit a couple of other, similar newsrooms this summer. It’s not so much about the reporting and editing. Those I can still do. And it’s not about trying to learn the latest video-editing software. That might only depress me. It’s about knowing the newsroom culture my students will step into once they graduate. Not just knowing about it. Knowing it. Only then can I help prepare them for it.

IU advising legend Adams has died

June 3, 2007 in Advising

dave adams blog

UPDATE 2: The IDS now has a special blog devoted to Dave Adams for those who want to drop by and share thoughts and memories.

UPDATE: You can read some about the impact Dave had on those he mentored at the IDS Deadline blog. Drop by and share your thoughts and memories there.

There’s no easy way to write that a giant in your industry is no longer here. Word out of Bloomington today is that IU’s Student Media Director David L. Adams died last night. Here’s the story from the Indiana Daily Student: IDS publisher dead at 59.

I’ll post more as I find out more. There’s a statement from CMA President Lance Speere on the CMA website:

CMA has lost a dear, dear friend. I’m stunned and saddened. I’ve known David since my earliest days in college media and he was someone I knew I could always count on both as a friend and a colleague. Words will never fully pay tribute to everything David has meant to student media and to so many people.

The CMA board will certainly look at ways to honor David’s memory, and we welcome any suggestions from the membership.

Our thoughts and prayers go out to David’s closest friends and family.

David has commented on our weblog previously, and we’d exchanged e-mails and greetings at conferences. His passion for student media and free expression are something we can all learn from in college media.

Our thoughts are with his family, friends and co-workers.

The conveyor belt

June 1, 2007 in Advising

Early summer is indeed a time for advisers to catch their breath, but there’s a big downside: Even though the students are gone, the news doesn’t stop.

Sometimes, daily journalism is like that old “I Love Lucy” episode where Lucy and Ethel are working in a candy factory. The news rolls at you faster than you can keep up.

From early May to mid-June, there’s no one at all minding the conveyor belt, but the news keeps coming. I keep a pile of clippings from the local daily, of press releases, of national stories that would be great to localize … knowing that when the students get back, they’ll gobble up a few of those stories, but others will pass unnoticed.

When I was relatively new at advising, that was one of the toughest things to get used to: the fact that, even at a good student newspaper, a lot of great potential stories go untouched. In the summer, at least there’s a better excuse because few students are here. It happens during the fall and spring semesters, too, though, and it’s one of those frustrations for an adviser: You can (and should) point out potential stories, but you can’t (and shouldn’t) make the students do those stories.

So you have some options:

1. Point out every day how many good stories they are missing. This can work in small doses, but do it too much and it’s demoralizing for even your best students.

2. Stop worrying about it and just let them find stories on their own, resigning yourself to the fact that they will miss some big ones and it will reflect poorly on them. This one’s no good because you abdicate part of your role as teacher.

3. Continue to point out good potential stories every day. Make peace with the inevitable fact that you are not the editor and that many of your story ideas will never see print. Realize that your job is to model the role of a good journalist without actually doing that journalism. And then model journalistic thinking – where everything in life is a potential story idea. Even if they don’t catch it all now – and they won’t – what you want is for them to develop that mindset. And they will.

That helps take your focus off the conveyor belt.

CMA newsletter spotlights Va. Tech tragedy

May 30, 2007 in Advising, Va. Tech Shooting

I don’t normally link to the CMA newsletter when it comes out, but the May/June issue features a couple of articles – by Kelly Furnas, editorial adviser at Va. Tech; and Dave Waddell of CSU-Chico – looking at the Va. Tech tragedy from the standpoint of advisers. Worth a read.

You can download a PDF of the newsletter here.

The value of alumni

May 24, 2007 in Advising

A big summer task here is assembling the annual Northern Star Alumni newsletter, which we call Telescope. We are blessed to count hundreds of people in our active and vigilant alumni group. Graduation years extend back to the late 1940s, back when the paper still was called “The Northern Illinois” (how’s that for pizzazz?).

And there aren’t many degrees of separation among our alumni. It’s a pretty tight family. Counting the two of us today (Business Adviser Maria Krull and myself), the Northern Star has had exactly four advisers in the past 46 years.

Keeping an open line of communication with your alumni takes time, but what an investment. Maria keeps track of the database and I manage the e-mail listserv, the Web site and an occasional blog. The e-mail list has proven especially helpful to us as advisers. We use it sparingly and only when truly needed – kind of like the Bat Signal, I guess. This past spring we posted information about the College Campus Press Act in Illinois. Many, many alums – some in high places in Chicago media – contacted their Illinois legislators to urge support for the bill. At other times, we’ve asked for and received advice about the future of the Star’s Web site, or input on a print redesign. When alums have won or been named finalists for Pulitzers, we’ve been able to get the word out quickly.

For the newsletter, we do a few news articles about the Star and its alumni and noteworthy happenings from the past year. Big attention is paid to our annual Hall of Fame induction. But by far, the most space is devoted to Alumni Updates – hundreds of blurbs people e-mail us about what they’re doing now.

Many of these alums endured free-press struggles here that helped pave the way for the freedoms our students enjoy today. At the annual Hall of Fame banquet, we strategically seat our current students with alums who used to have the same jobs here. Sometimes this has led to mentoring relationships, job connections … or even just a sympathetic ear when struggling with a particular newsroom issue.

So, my point in all of this is that an alumni group can be a huge support system for student media, and especially for advisers. It’s worth the time to establish and maintain.

We’ll have this year’s newsletter out in mid- to late June, I hope. At that point, I’ll link to it for anyone interested.

Summer at last

May 23, 2007 in Advising

Here’s installment No. 1 from me, in a blog about advising college media.

Summer’s here, at least in academia. In our world here, that means going, overnight, from 100 mph to about 10 mph. The students won’t be back for another month, and it’s eerily quiet in this newsroom. Time to clean house, literally. I rolled a big trash bin over to my office door yesterday and have been raising a dust cloud by pitching stuff. Piles of newspapers. Scraps of paper with irrelevant notes from last September. More piles of newspapers. Folders full of articles and instructional handouts that I saved and read, but now have little use.

I was born with a packrat gene. (Want proof? Here you go.) My offices, both at work and at home, are crammed with boxes of newspapers, sports and journalism memorabilia. Most of it is useless to anyone but me (and honestly, most of it is useless to me, too). “Someday when I die,” I tell my kids, “all of this will be yours.” No such promises here at the Star, so I perform my annual May ritual. This year I’m going even deeper into the dust. Some of the stuff I’m dumping, I haven’t touched in years. I tell myself, “I think I’ll be OK without these writers workshop notes from 1998.” As of this writing, the dishwasher-sized trash bin is two-thirds full. I’m going to need another one by later today.

Housecleaning is something I never had time to do when I was an editor and reporter, because there never was a down period. Every day of every year, you feed the monster. So the junk just piles up – both literally and figuratively. One of the best parts about college media, for advisers, is that there’s always a finish line in sight. Maybe life and a career are best tackled in bite-sized chunks, with seasonal opportunities to digest, reassess and look ahead. It certainly takes the stress level down. That’s something I remind myself during the more frustrating days of advising: That this is a pretty good life, and one that a lot of my friends in the newspaper biz would kill for. I’ll take vacation time in the coming days and weeks, work ahead on staff training plans for late summer, visit a few newsrooms in our area, and learn some multimedia skills I’ve needed to catch up on. For this week, though, it’s back to the dust cloud.