You are browsing the archive for College Media News.

Not the sort of innovation we need

April 7, 2009 in College Media News, ethics

Update 2: another take from the Daily Cal.

The Daily Bruin at UCLA ran a “wrap” advertisement around their paper today. Ordinarily, I have no problem with “innovative” advertising ideas (well, except for those cursed roll-over web ads), but this ad went way beyond “innovative” and ventured into the area of “deceptive” and “unethical.”

Here’s the real Bruin front page:

bruin

And here’s the “wrap” that ran today:

fake front

Now, I don’t know about you, but, with the exception of the “Paid Advertisement” words below the flag, that’s a pretty close knock-off of the editorial design of the real Daily Bruin (the editorial staff did get the advertiser to change the font on the nameplate of the ad). All to market some kind of honey-related ice cream crap.

The student editors weren’t pleased, and said so in an editorial:

Many of us volunteered to forfeit our pay in order to ensure that the ad would not run, but because some of our staff members could not afford to use their paychecks to make a statement, we have been forced to go along quietly.

The reality of our financial situation is grim, and the fact of the matter is that we would have been forced to cut thousands of dollars from an ever-tightening budget if we had not run this advertisement.

We were forced to make a decision we find distasteful at best – and dishonest and unethical at worst – because of the ever-present and unrelenting reality of the economy and the downturn of the journalism industry.

Much of our staff, the members of this board especially, are invested in the Daily Bruin and the practice of journalism on a personal level, and nothing pains us more than to see the cover and name of our beloved publication sullied for the sake of survival.

Editor Anthony Pesce published an editor’s note on the real front page:

Today’s Daily Bruin was wrapped in an advertisement specifically designed by a clever marketing department to fool you into thinking – if only for a few seconds – that my staff wrote the content that appeared on the front page.

If you’re reading this, you have discovered our real front page, fully educated about the plight of the honey bee, and I’m glad you are taking the time to read our newspaper. I want our readership and our community to know that there will not be another advertisement like it for the rest of the year. We will not be selling these kinds of ads as long as I remain the editor of this newspaper – which is at least for another nine weeks. Many on my staff were vehemently opposed to this ad for a variety of reasons. Mostly, though, they were upset and concerned that our front-page news content was displaced, and that it was displaced by an advertisement designed to mislead our readers.

Apparently, financial pressures overruled journalism in this instance. I’m with the students.

Look, it’s one thing to place an ad around your content. It’s one thing to think up new ways to make money on innovative marketing ideas. Heck, I even applauded when the New York Times started running front page ads!

But this is just wrong. Shame on the marketers for concocting this sad little ploy to trade on the tradition of a 90-year-old journalistic enterprise, and shame on whoever it was who forced the issue to trade that journalistic tradition for a few pieces of gold.

In an age when newspapers are fighting for their lives and the credibility of the news industry is not that great, this type of “advertorial” is not a step in the right direction.

I welcome your thoughts.

Update: Please answer the poll question

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

ICM interview: Joe Weasel of Palestra.net/Uwire

March 26, 2009 in College Media News, Interviews

palestra.png

Following up on yesterday’s news that Palestra.net purchased UWire.com from CBS, I spoke to Joe Weasel, CEO of the company, about the purchase. Below are some notes from the interview. (Also be sure to check out Dan Reimold’s interview)

First off, to dispel a misunderstanding, NewsCorp. (read: FOX News) does not own Palestra.net. Weasel said NewsCorp. owns a small stake in the company, but most of the funding for the start-up came from more than 50 individuals. “We didn’t go the venture capital route,” Weasel said. Palestra.net does have distribution deals with FOX and other media companies.

uwire_logo.gif

The sale of Uwire was completed at the first of the year, but the final contractual agreements were only signed recently. The company will maintain distribution deals that UWire already had with outlets like CNN and CBS, among others.

Weasel said the new company would keep the UWire name and begin transitioning their 152 digital college journalists to the UWire brand. However, the Palestra music site will stay with that brand, as Weasel said the brand is more recognized in the music industry.

Weasel said he does not anticipate much of a change in the way UWire works with college newspapers, but he does see the new combined entity as a way to provide more opportunities to get student content out there and also help student newspapers.

“What we have to do, we have to find ways to pick up where Ben (French, UWire founder former general manager – my error, not Mr. Weasel’s – ed.) left off and find new avenues not only for students to find exposure, but find ways for papers to generate traffic,” he said. “We have to find ways of being a bridge to the future. UWire’s got to be more active in being a bridge to the future.”

Weasel said his print background (he’s worked in tv, radio and print, and also taught journalism at Ohio State) makes him bullish on college newspapers.

“The biggest message we have is the school paper is the best place for (student journalists) to start,” he said. He said most of Palestra’s digital journalists are juniors and seniors, “students who have written for the paper for a couple of years.”

One of the emphases of the new organization will be trying to address the future of college media.

“It’s important that the college papers survive and thrive,” Weasel said. “We’re going to try to help drive traffic to them. right now the way UWire distributes content, it’s noted by paper and student. We’re going to be creating some ways where some of that content can be used as traffic drivers to the sites. Schools will notice heavier emphasis on helping drive traffic to school papers.”

He hopes that the combination of Palestra’s online video emphasis and UWire’s emphasis on college newspapers will make for a good combination.

“Ultimately, when you bring these two together, that puts the strongest organization out front,” Weasel said. “The combined resources allows us to do initiatives … things that might be really important for getting jobs in the future.”

“I get concerned when I see college papers go totally online or three-day a week,” Weasel said. “We’re watching regular newspapers go out of busines. We have to be an innovator in helping papers get exposure, try to help them with models that will increase their own exposure.”

Weasel also said UWire will continue to work with Associated Collegiate Press and College Media Advisers, Inc. as a sponsor. “Hopefully we’ll be more involved with them,” he said.

Palestra.net pays college journalists to produce primarily video content for the site, focused on stories with broader appeal than on campus (which Weasel says differentiates their coverage from traditional college newspapers).

Analysis: All in all, the UWire/Palestra combination seems like a pretty good fit. We’ll have to see how it plays out, as Weasel said there will be some new educational initiatives announced over the coming months.

The thing that is promising about the deal is that it puts UWire in the fold with a company that is focused on college journalism in a way that CBS was not.That’s not a knock on CBS, it’s just reality.

There are advantages to being part of a huge media conglomerate – like greater access to resources and distribution channels. But there are disadvantages too. In a company the size of CBS, a unit like UWire might be mistaken for a rounding error.

If the combination of UWire and Palestra works to help college media generate more online revenue and gain greater exposure for college journalists, then it will be a good thing in the long run.

Thoughts? Please respond in the comments.

Breaking: Palestra.net buys Uwire.com

March 25, 2009 in College Media News

Palestra.net, an online college news network, has purchased UWire.com from CBS. More details will be coming soon.

The integration of two different models of news distribution is of primary interest. UWire functions a lot like an Associated Press for college news orgs. Palestra.net has been operating outside the traditional college media sphere. Stay tuned. There’s supposed to be a press release coming out soon. Ben French is staying with CBS as VP for strategy and product development for cbsnews.com.

UWire 100 ’09 – nominations now

March 4, 2009 in College Media News, hope for the future

uwire 100Last year, we here at ICM were proud to showcase seven of the UWire 100, seven who had been participating in the Innovation in College Media web site, and whose nominations we supported.

The UWire 100 is back again this year, and they’re looking for top college journalists. Here’s the nomination form. Deadline is March 10, so don’t delay!

This year, I could probably name many more to nominate (several from Twitter or Collegejourn.com). Who do you think is a “top 100″college journalist this year? If you asked me (which they didn’t), that journalist had better have some mad multi-platform skills.

Daily Emerald editorial staff goes on strike

March 4, 2009 in College Media News, industry news

daily emerald strikeEffective 6 a.m. March 4, the news staff of University of Oregon’s student newspaper is on strike in attempt to preserve the integrity, independence and future of the Daily Emerald.

The Emerald’s protest comes after Steven A. Smith,  an alum and former editor in chief of The Spokesman Review, was hired to draft a strategic plan for the publication — including creation of a supervisory “publisher” position, which the staff believes will  pressure editors into waiving control of the paper:

The editors felt that the Emerald cannot afford the salary Smith proposed, and were extremely concerned that allowing Smith to work as an adjunct instructor at the journalism school while serving as publisher was an obvious conflict of interest, for multiple reasons.

An article written by the editor in chief and managing editor stated, “We need someone who has a tangible plan to start making money.”

The staff wants the following four demands met in order to “preserve student control and editorial independence” of the publication:

1. Immediately rescind the offer to Steven A. Smith to serve as interim publisher April 1, 2009 through June 30, 2010. (Update: Smith resigned, read his blog post here).

2. Conduct a nationwide search for a publisher, as originally voted at the Feb. 10 board meeting.

3. Stipulate in the chosen publisher’s contract that he or she shall not be employed in any capacity by the University, including at the School of Journalism and Communication.

4. Stipulate in the chosen publisher’s contract that he or she shall not have immediate supervisory control over the editor; rather, the publisher and student editor shall remain equals in the organization, as the general manager and student editor currently are.

The full article and text of the speech the editors presented to the Board of Directors is here.

Twitter updates related to the strike (#ODEstrike) are here.

The Daily Emerald started a staff strike blog and a Facebook page for the cause.

Ball State Daily News cuts confirmed

February 16, 2009 in College Media News

Last week, we noted some recent announcements from college newspapers cutting their Friday editions. Here’s the letter from the editor of the Ball State Daily News.

Samantha Zilal puts the best possible spin on the decision:

Suspending Friday publication is not a death sentence, and our Friday papers may be back someday. As the country struggles financially this is something that will tide us over until the economy bounces back.

Instead of sitting in a corner lamenting the glory days of print media, we’re going to do something we should have done a long time ago: Use our Web site for what it was intended and be a true, daily news source.

Tough times, tough measures. Not much to add to that.

More Fridays going

February 12, 2009 in College Media News

Reading the newspaper: Brookgreen Gardens in P...Image via Wikipedia

 UPDATE: CollegeRag reports that BSU’s Daily News will also cease Friday publication soon and cut circulation by 4,000. The news hasn’t shown up on the DN web site yet. I’ll link when it does. Oh, and how did I miss this from the California Aggie.

Via Dan Reimold, note that Boston U.’s Daily Free Press will stop printing an edition on Fridays.

The editors say the move is “temporary.”

Also, the Washington Square News is looking at a proposal to drop Friday publication as well.

At WSN, there are other cuts taking place:

The changes, which have not yet been brought to the board for an official vote, would also call for publishing magazines online-only and canceling summer issues. While no staff reductions would take place, editors’ stipends will decrease 23 percent regardless of the board’s decision. Smith said there was a “pretty good possibility” the proposal would pass as early as Wednesday.

Reimold says the changes may benefit college journalists in the long run:

The who-cares content that has far too long frequented newspaper pages simply because there is space to fill or another day’s issue to put out is a thing of the past.  The Friday-less student press now has more of an opportunity to fill their remaining print issues each week with only the stories that matter most to its readers, leaving the crappier content out of print, as it belongs.

We’ll see. In my MediaShift article last month, I noted that there are a lot of college newspapers facing some big financial questions. And given the economic forecast for the next year to 18 months (it’s not pretty), my prediction is more of these announcements will come, probably in time for the fall semester.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

College Media twittering

February 3, 2009 in College Media News, Twitter

Image representing Twitter as depicted in Crun...Image via CrunchBase

Inspired by an e-mail on the CMA Listserv, I just put together this short list of college media outlets who are on Twitter, just from those who are following CICM. I know I’m missing folks, so if you would like to add your college media outlet, fill out this form to add it to the list.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

College news covers the inauguration

January 14, 2009 in College Media News

WASHINGTON - NOVEMBER 05:  Construction worker...Image by Getty Images via DaylifeNext Monday, I’ll be rolling out another list post of college news outlets who are sending reporters/photogs to cover the inauguration of Barack Obama as the first African-American president of the United States.

I already have a list of about 10 school newspapers. If your school is doing something for the inauguration, even if it’s covering from a local angle, drop me an e-mail at scmurley -at- gmail.com or add a link in the comments to this post.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

CoPress offering hosting solution for college media looking to strike out on their own

December 30, 2008 in College Media News, College Publisher, CoPress, Websites, Wordpress

copress hosting

Yesterday, the student technologists at CoPress (where I host the podcast) announced something that’s been several months in the making: A hosting solution with CMS for college media.

This is an effort that takes a different approach from the dominant business model in college news hosting, that of College Publisher. Whereas College Publisher hosts web sites for “free” and generates income from selling national ads for premium placement across their network, the CoPress model is paid for through an upfront monthly fee, with the college media outlet selling its own advertising stock.

And with the economy in dicey shape, college media need to get serious about generating more income from diverse sources like the web site. Some are doing more along these lines, but there’s a long way to go for most.

If nothing else, putting the hosting of the web site into a budget as an expense might give colleges some incentive to push online ads where now they are likely neglected (the Daily Eastern News has no online ads at the moment, so I’m preaching to my own paper here).

The fact that the hosting plan is offering a WordPress install means there’s a large number of people and technical support available out there to assist with problems (in addition to the CoPress team). The CoPress team can even help transition College Publisher archives into the WP format.

I doubt the CoPress effort will pose a serious threat to College Publisher’s business right now, but it’s another option for college media to consider, and that’s always a good thing.

I’ve been a proponent of this business model for a couple of years now, but it’s been a challenge putting together the pieces to offer this type of program. Now, it’s good to see this effort coming from committed journalism students.

I hope some advisers come on board and offer support where needed. Miles Skorpen at Swarthmore is heading up the hosting part of CoPress, and he definitely knows his stuff.

Others noting this announcement:

Ryan Sholin: I’ve had a chance to talk, chat, and tweet with some of the students and recent graduates behind CoPress over the last few months, and I think they’re clearly the sharpest minds in online student media right now.

Dan Riemold:  CoPress seems to be the future. It is determined to make student news sites that are student-friendly and UNIQUE to each and every outlet and campus. The results of its efforts of course are still pending but the (CoPress) team oozes passion, relevant experience, and new media sensibilities.

Greg Linch (a CoPress leader): But, whereas our situation allowed us to make the move on our own, many school papers don’t have a server or the technical know-how to make such a move. Or, if you do, you can avoid a possible headache (particularly in transfering your College Publisher archives) with a little help from your friends. That’s where CoPress comes in – we can do all that.

If you’re interested in a fuller explanation of CoPress, you can listen to this podcast interview I conducted with Kevin Koehler in October.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]